Additives Used in Blood: Variable Safety for Human Consumption

vacutainerbloodbottles

By Lethenteron, Syrf and CJ!

Of the many techniques sanguinarians use to draw their donors’ blood, one of the most effective, for those who get trained or have a trained donor, is phlebotomy.  Vacuum-infused blood collection tubes allow for a clean draw and a precise quantity. [n1]

There are a myriad of different additives used in blood collection, each with specific properties. This post discusses the utility of certain chemicals as they are presented in prepared phlebotomy blood collection containers. Heparin, EDTA and tri-sodium citrate might be used slightly differently and in different ratios if you are adding the raw materials to the blood yourself. [n2]

Some of those chemicals are toxic in certain quantities and potentially harmful if ingested too frequently. Here, I provide personal experience along with a concise literature review of the relevant properties and known toxicity of each additive cited.

For the purpose of this post, it’s relevant to point out we will be using the color code used by  BD Brand Vacutainers, a widely used supplier. Other brands may use different color codes. Pay attention and know what you’re getting, other brands not mentioned in this article may use a different color code and contain materials that should not be ingested.

Here is a guide to BD Vacutainer colours :

https://www.bd.com/vacutainer/pdfs/plus_plastic_tubes_wallchart_tubeguide_VS5229.pdf

Here I’ll speak about the following 4 types of vacutainers :

– No additive

– Sodium Heparin

– Trisodium Citrate

– k2EDTA or k3EDTA

And the additive most commonly found in blood collection bags :

– Citrate phosphate dextrose adenine (CPDA-1)

(A small disclaimer: Blood collection tubes are specifically for use in blood analysis. They are NOT intended to collect blood that will be infused in a patient or consumed as a food or medical item. In this sense, the use of vacutainers with additives necessarily comes with a non-negligible risk and it is at your own discretion that you may use them for that purpose.)

Plain Tube / No additive

vacutainerplaintube

Blood is drawn into vacutainers without additive.

The major disadvantage of using a no additive tube is that drawn blood will coagulate rapidly and the contents of the vial must be ingested quickly. The main advantage, however, is the peace of mind of getting additive-free blood, with no toxicity concerns or possible interactions or alteration of the blood by the chemicals.

Conclusions:

Safety: No additional risks beyond the expected risks associated with the ingestion of blood.

Sodium Heparin (Na Heparin)

sodiumheparintube

Unfractionated heparin and low molecular weight heparin are the most commonly used antithrombotic and thromboprophylactic agents in hospital practice. It is also used to form an inner anticoagulant surface on various experimental and medical devices such as test tubes and renal dialysis machines.

Heparin acts as an anticoagulant, preventing the formation of clots and extension of existing clots within the blood, preventing venous thromboembolism. It is also increasingly recognized that heparin has many other pharmacological properties including but not limited to antiviral, anti-inflammatory, and antimetastatic actions. (Mulloy et al, 2016)

However, heparin must be given parenterally (administered in a manner other than through the digestive tract) for it to be effective for thinning the blood within the body. When given orally, the body digests it before it can be made of any use. This is why a lot of research has gone toward finding ways to administer heparin orally with the help of specialised, carrier molecules. (Arbit et al, 2006)

Conclusions:

Safety: No known toxicity, inactivated by digestion, generally safe.

Word of caution: Pharmaceutical-grade heparin is derived from mucosal tissues of slaughtered meat animals such as porcine (pig) intestines or bovine (cattle) lungs. There have been recalls of commonly used injectable heparin due to risks of bacterial contamination. It is not known if the risks are lower or higher with spray coated heparin in collection tubes.

Note:

Vacutainers containing any additive mentioned here must be gently inverted (turned upside down) 8-10 times to ensure that the additive with be properly mixed into the blood. [n1.3]

Blood preserved with heparin tends to separate [n1.5]. when left static and will eventually start to form clots after 4/5 days.

Sodium Citrate (Trisodium citrate)

sodiumcitrate

Sodium citrate is chiefly used as a food additive, usually for flavor or as a preservative. Its E number (a code for food additives) is E331. Sodium citrate is employed as a tart flavoring agent in certain varieties of club soda and commercial ready to drink beverages and drink mixes. Sodium citrate is common as an ingredient in bratwurst, ice-cream, jams, sweets, milk powder, processed cheeses, carbonated beverages, and wine.

In 1914, the Belgian doctor Albert Hustin and the Argentine physician and researcher Luis Agote successfully used sodium citrate as an anticoagulant in blood transfusions. It continues to be used today in blood collection tubes and for the preservation of blood in blood banks. The citrate ion chelates calcium ions in the blood by forming calcium citrate complexes, disrupting the blood clotting mechanism.

Toxicology of Sodium Citrate

http://chem.sis.nlm.nih.gov/chemidplus/rn/68-04-2

Conclusions:

Safety: Generally safe. Sometimes used to preserve animal blood for cooking. Contraindication for people with impaired renal function.

Note: Sodium Citrate does add a tart, slightly salty flavor to the blood and for this reason, may be less preferable to the person ingesting the blood than tasteless additives.

Sodium Citrate vacutainers must be inverted 3-4 times, gently (Vigorous mixing or shaking of a specimen may cause hemolysis, which means rupture or laceration of the cell walls. There is some indication that preservation of intact red cells is relevant for our purpose, though there is no conclusive evidence I’m aware of to support this).

 

EDTA

BD Vacutainer® K2 EDTA Blood Collection Tube

Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, widely abbreviated as EDTA is a chelating agent (a substance whose molecules can form several bonds to a single metal ion) that is widely used  by various industries. Various forms of EDTA are used as ingredients in cosmetics, pesticides, household disinfectants, laundry detergent, eye drops and are frequently added to food as a preservative. In laboratories, EDTA is used extensively in the analysis of blood as an anticoagulant for blood samples for CBC/FBEs.

An important use of EDTA is in the treatment of heavy metal poisoning (lead and mercury) and in the treatment of excess iron in the blood. Injected intravenously, once in the bloodstream EDTA traps lead and other metals forming a compound that the body can eliminate in the urine.

(EDTA dipotassium salt dihydrate & EDTA Tripotassium Salt)

K2 EDTA is available in a spray-dried form, which does not introduce dilutional effects on small sample volumes. It is associated with a less pronounced osmotic effect on blood cells than K3 EDTA, but it appears to be associated with more complaints regarding blood clotting. In fact, as K2 EDTA is dispensed as a powder on the inside walls of the vial, primary tubes containing this additive may need to be properly mixed to allow a complete miscibility between the blood and the anticoagulant.

Studies published by the The International Council for Standardization in Haematology and NCCLS show morphological alterations to the blood cells are more pronounced when K3-EDTA is used than K2-EDTA [n3]. We may want to take this into consideration.  Basically, K3-EDTA osmotically shrinks the red cells, and being liquid rather than a salt spray, dilutes the sample. Further dilution expands the red cells to normal size during medical analysis which is why the effect is often considered negligible, but seeing as we’re skipping the laboratory analysis and guzzling it instead, I’d go with Dipotassium EDTA.

While the CLSI US Standard for Venous Blood Collection declines to differentiate between K2-EDTA and K3-EDTA as separate options for use as an anticoagulant [n2], the International Council for Standardization in Hematology currently recommends K2 EDTA as the anticoagulant of choice for hematological testing. This indication has been widely acknowledged in Europe and Japan, whereas K3 EDTA is still frequently used in the United States and the United Kingdom.

By binding to the calcium in blood, EDTA effectively prevents the coagulation cascade and irreversibly prevents blood clotting so it will always remain in a fluid state.

The anticoagulant of choice in routine haematology https://www.researchgate.net/publication/21362193_K2 HYPERLINK 

Safety Data Sheet for K3EDTA

*Note: K2-EDTA light and heat sensitive. [n2.5]

Some proponents of alternative medicine claim that EDTA, particularly calcium Disodium EDTA, when taken orally acts as an antioxidant and helps fight cardiovascular diseases and improves blood flow. However, these ideas not yet conclusive, and seem to contradict some currently accepted principles. The proposed health benefits of oral chelations therapies have not been proven to be effective (Green 2009).

An example of a product sold as an oral chelation therapy consisting of a “Proprietary blend of 3 types of Sodium based EDTA, which are all food-grade amino acids” is [n4]. Their pills are sold in 450 mg doses, with the recommended daily dose for the first two weeks being 2.7 grams per day. Meanwhile WebMD states that “It is UNSAFE to use more than 3 grams of EDTA per day, or to take it longer than 5 to 7 days. Too much can cause kidney damage, dangerously low calcium levels, and death.” [n5] For comparison, a standard EDTA vacutainer will contain up to 10 milligrams of k3EDTA. One would have to consume 300 vials in one day to consume 3 grams of EDTA.

Safety:

This report:  http://gov.personalcarecouncil.org/ctfa-static/online/lists/cir-pdfs/FR285.pdf  is a mine of information on EDTA toxicity, both oral, intravenous and cutaneous. It summarizes pretty much all of the human and animal studies performed on the toxicity of EDTA for the past 20 years. Here are the most relevant points for the purposes of consumption.

Continued use of oral EDTA has been shown to result in a loss of necessary trace metals, such a zinc and calcium, which can lead to complications and heart disease. The CIR Expert Panel recognized that oral exposures to EDTA produced reproductive/ developmental toxicity in test animals. Demineralization of teeth was also observed.

It is important to note that we are not aware of any studies having been conducted regarding on the effects of oral ingestion of K2-EDTA and K3-EDTA. There are important differences in the way the human body metabolizes EDTA in it’s various forms and without further knowledge we cannot at this time predict the health consequences of using this anticoagulant for blood preservation for the purpose of ingestion other than to use previous studies as a guide.[n6]

Conclusions:

Oral use of EDTA in humans has never been studied in a large group of people and over a long enough period of time to determine the safe dose and the extent of resulting trace element deficiencies. The information available on oral toxicity of EDTA on animals is sometimes conflicting. The long-term toxicity of EDTA is complicated by its ability to chelate essential and toxic metals, both in water and in animals. Toxicity data are therefore equivocal and difficult to interpret.

There is no sufficient evidence to say that EDTA consumed regularly is entirely safe.  There are serious concerns that its continued use might create deficiencies in trace metals such a zinc and calcium; damage teeth by means of demineralization and damage different tissues of the gastrointestinal tract. While the quantities present in vacutainers might not be enough to cause  toxicological effects, caution should be advised. I would definitely not recommend the use of EDTA for Sanguinarians who need frequent and heavy feedings.

K2-EDTA is considered hazardous by the 2012 OSHA Hazard Communication Standard [n6.5]

Citrate phosphate dextrose adenine (CPDA-1)

cpdabag

Additive most often found in blood collection bags.

An anticoagulant solution, containing citric acid, sodium citrate, monobasic sodium phosphate, dextrose, and adenine, used for the preservation of whole blood and red blood cells for up to 35 days; it extends red cell survival by providing adenine needed for the maintenance of red cell ATP.

(http://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/CPDA-1)

Conclusions:

Safety: Thought safe to drink.

note:

CPDA-1 has a very long shelf life but I find it to have a strong, nearly cloying taste.

————————————————————————————————————————-

[n1] Any blood drawing should only be done by someone who is trained to do so or risk injury to the donor. Any individual choosing to draw blood and consume it does so at their own discretion, responsibility, and risk.

[n1.3] Regarding invertion of vacutainers for activation of anticoalgulents:

http://www.bd.com/vacutainer/pdfs/techtalk/TechTalk_Jan2004_VS7167.pdf

[n1.5]  A visual guide to blood seperation:

http://www.redcrossblood.org/learn-about-blood/blood-components

[n2] A discussion on how to prepare EDTA as anticoagulant for human blood collection :

https://www.researchgate.net/post/How_to_prepare_EDTA_as_anticoagulant_for_human_blood_collection

[n2.5] Details regarding preffered storage methods of EDTA including sensativity to heat and sunlight:  https://www.fishersci.com/shop/msdsproxy?storeId=10652&productName=AC409965000&productDescription=

[n3] https://www.bd.com/vacutainer/pdfs/techtalk/TechTalk_May2002_VS5998.pdf

http://www.bd.com/vacutainer/pdfs/techtalk/TechTalk_Jan2009_VS8014.pdf.

[n3.5] CLSI US Standard for Venous Blood Collection:

https://www.sarstedt.com/fileadmin/user_upload/99_Literatur/US/619_EDTA_Antikoagulantien_US.pdf

[n4] An example of a webite selling oral chelation pills found here: http://cardiorenewcanada.ca/6weekfoundationprogram.php

[n5] Article noting an decrease in clotting time associated with K2-EDTA when compared to K3-EDTA: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/568506_4

[n6] An article discussing the differences in various forms of EDTA as they pertain to oral chelation therapy: http://www.smart-publications.com/articles/the-business-of-chelation-and-why-EDTA-oral-chelation-is-best

[n6.5] K2-EDTA- OSHA Hazard Communication Standard:

https://www.fishersci.com/shop/msdsproxy?storeId=10652&productName=AC409965000&productDescription=

[n7] WebMD’s health warnings regarding EDTA: http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredientmono-1032-edta.aspx?activeingredientid=1032&

————————————————————————————————————————-

Mulloy, B., J Hogwood, E Gray, R Lever, CP Page. “Pharmacology of Heparin and Related Drugs.” Pharmacology Review. 2016 Jan;68(1):76-141

Ehud Arbit,  Michael Goldberg, Isabel Gomez-Orellana, and Shingai Majuru.Thromb J, 2006. “Oral heparin: status review” Thrombosis Journal. 10 May 2006, 4:6 

Arzoumanian, Lena. “Tech Talk.” BD. Retrived February 2, 2016 <https://www.bd.com/vacutainer/pdfs/techtalk/TechTalk_May2002_VS5998.pdf>

Brown, M. J.; Willis, T.; Omalu, B.; Leiker, R. (2006). “Deaths Resulting from Hypocalcemia After Administration of Edetate Disodium: 2003-2005”. Pediatrics 118 (2): e534.

Green, Saul; Wallace Sampson. December 14, 2002. “EDTA Chelation Therapy for Atherosclerosis And Degenerative Diseases: Implausibility and Paradoxical Oxidant Effects”. Quackwatch. Retrieved 16 December 2009. <http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/chelationimp.html>

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s